With Skillful Hands

When a Volunteer Needs to be Fired

When a Volunteer Needs to be Fired

June 26, 2014 By Mike Leave a Comment

In Peter Drucker’s book The Effective Executive you’ll read the following story:

General Marshall during World War II insisted that a general officer be immediately relieved if found less than outstanding. Marshall flatly refused to listen to the argument: “But we have no replacement.” “All that matters,” he pointed out, “is that you know that this man is not equal to the task. Where his replacement comes from is the next question.”

Sometimes we are scared to do the right thing because of the potential consequences. For example, I once had a belligerent teenager serving in our worship arts department when I was a youth pastor in Maryland. After I warned him several times and he still didn’t listen, I decided he needed to be let go. But I was scared to do what was right because I didn’t know who would replace him. But I concluded (as General Marshall did) that this man was not equal to the task. Where his replacement would come from was the next question.

It’s scary to do the right thing sometimes, but I have learned that when we do what is right, God honors us, and helps things to work out. Asking “But who will replace them?” is the wrong question. The right question is “What is the right thing to do in this situation?” Once you’ve determined the right course to take, you act, and leave the rest to God. That’s what I did with my belligerent teenage volunteer, and let me tell you that God provided us with a new (and much more qualified) volunteer, who served in that role for almost four years, and did so with a great attitude. I wonder what I would’ve missed out on had I decided to let the potential consequences scare me out of doing what I knew was right. I wonder what you’re missing out on right now if you haven’t acted on something you know is the right thing to do because you are scared of the consequences. Do what’s right and let the chips fall where they may. Then trust God to work it all out.

Filed Under: Volunteers

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Fill out form to receive Mike’s latest posts via text

Recent Posts

  • Staying Fresh in the Pulpit
  • The Unenviable Job of a Leader
  • Core Four: Evaluate
  • A Thanksgiving Devotional
  • How to Respond Appropriately to Criticism

Categories

  • Culture
  • Failures
  • Finances
  • How To
  • Leadership
  • Management
  • Position Papers
  • Preaching
  • Resources
  • Scripture
  • Staff
  • Uncategorized
  • Vendors
  • Volunteers

Design

With an emphasis on typography, white space, and mobile-optimized design, your website will look absolutely breathtaking.

Learn more about design.

Content

Our team will teach you the art of writing audience-focused content that will help you achieve the success you truly deserve.

Learn more about content.

Strategy

We help creative entrepreneurs build their digital business by focusing on three key elements of a successful online platform.

Learn more about strategy.

Copyright © 2026 With Skillful Hands & Mike Sorcinelli